Top Jewelry Gifts for Valentine’s Day 2023

valentine's day gifts

Valentine’s Day is a special time to show the people in your life that you love them. Whether you’re looking for a romantic gift or a friendly one, we have many jewelry options at Shane Co. that say “I love you.” We know there’s a lot to navigate when purchasing a gift, though, like price, personal style, and the message you want to send with the gift. Below, we uncover our top Valentine’s Day gift recommendations for 2023. If you’re in need of a last-minute gift, check out our guide for the perfect piece that you can get right before Valentine’s Day.

Discover Gifts Within Your Budget

Setting a budget is a great starting point when purchasing a gift. This Valentine’s Day, you may be buying a gift for someone you just started dating, you may want to splurge for a special occasion like an anniversary, or you may want to treat yourself to something sweet. Either way, there’s something for every budget at Shane Co.

Gifts Under $250

If you’re looking for something sentimental that won’t break the bank, consider one of these gifts under $250.

Bonnie White Sapphire Heart Necklace

This gorgeous heart-shaped necklace features a stunning white sapphire. It’s crafted with sterling silver and is the perfect way to show someone you love them. 

sapphire heart necklace

Vertical Gold Bar Earrings

These lovely gold bar earrings are perfect for a casual, classy gift anyone will love. Get these earrings for anyone with chic style in your life.

Gifts Under $500

If you’re looking at a slightly higher price range, check out a couple of our favorite gifts under $500 below. 

Bondi Morganite and Diamond Pendant

This beautiful morganite pendant features a peach morganite set in stunning rose gold. It’s sure to capture anyone’s attention and win their affection.

Mae Diamond Infinity Ring 

We love the symbolism behind this Mae Diamond Infinity Ring! It features 18 round pavé-set diamonds. It’s crafted with quality sterling silver. 

Gifts Under $1,000

Explore gifts under $1,000 for an elevated expression of love that shows just how much they mean to you. 

Talia Reversible Diamond and Black Sapphire Hoop Earrings

Featuring 22 sparkling diamonds and 22 black sapphires, these hoop earrings are available in 14k yellow or white gold and are a great choice anyone is sure to love.

Monaco Garnet and Diamond Ring

One emerald cut garnet takes center stage in this ring with a baguette garnet on both sides and 18 accenting round diamonds.

Gifts Over $1,000

Want to splurge on a special gift this Valentine’s Day? Look no further than these gifts priced over $1,000

Mosaic Pink Sapphire and Diamond Ring

Crafted with rose gold, this Mosaic Pink Sapphire and Diamond Ring showcases a floral design holding 36 round pink sapphires and 15 round diamonds. 

Natural Diamond Tennis Bracelet

This mesmerizing Natural Diamond Tennis Bracelet features a bold design that is sure to stun. It’s available in white gold or yellow gold. 

diamond tennis bracelet

Explore Gifts by Jewelry Type

Another great way to narrow down your favorites when shopping for a gift is by selecting the type of jewelry you want to buy and going from there. Choose from necklaces, bracelets, rings, and earrings to browse some amazing Valentine’s Day gifts that will make them blush. 


You can’t go wrong with a beautiful necklace that always stays close to their heart! Here are a couple of our favorite Valentine’s Day selections. 

Bijou Petite Diamond Heart Necklace

Nothing says Valentine’s Day like this heart-shaped necklace! Available in rose gold, yellow gold, and white gold, it features 16 brilliant diamonds that sparkle and shine. 

heart pendant

Infinity Black and White Sapphire Pendant

If your love isn’t into hearts or traditional Valentine’s Day vibes, they may love this black and white sapphire pendant instead. Crafted from sterling silver, this necklace features a pear-shaped black sapphire and three round white sapphires. 


Bracelets are another great way to express your love this Valentine’s Day. We pulled two of our top picks below. 

Horizontal Bar Bracelet

This bracelet, while beautiful on its own, is extra special because you can engrave it with a meaningful message. 

Ambrose Bezel-Set Diamond Bracelet

We also love this Ambrose Bezel-Set Diamond Bracelet that features a modern style with five bezel-set round diamonds. It’s available in yellow gold, rose gold, and white gold. 

bezel-set diamond bracelet


A ring is a classic gift that symbolizes your everlasting love, whether or not it’s intended as a proposal present. Check out a couple of our stylish rings below. 

Annecy Cultured Akoya Pearl and Diamond Ring

This stunning pearl and diamond ring is a piece they’ll love that goes with every outfit. It stands out with akoya pearls and accenting natural diamonds for a bit of glamorous shimmer. 

Toi et Moi London Blue Topaz and White Sapphire Ring

We love this Toi et Moi ring that symbolizes the love the two of you share. With a heart-shaped stone, it’s perfect for Valentine’s Day. For the colorful gemstone, choose between a sapphire, garnet, or amethyst. 

toi et moi sapphire ring


Finally, everyone loves earrings. They can serve as a special romantic gift or a more subtle one for a new love. Either way, just like you and your partner, they make the perfect pair!

Ombré Pink Sapphire Earrings

Perfect for Valentine’s Day, these pink sapphire earrings are available in white gold, yellow gold, and rose gold and feature six multi-colored pink sapphires. 

pink sapphire earrings

Liri Hoop Earrings

These Liri Hoop Earrings go with everything. They’re available in white gold, yellow gold, and rose gold and offer a polished look. 

Find the Perfect Gift for That Special Someone

You may be looking for a gift for the man in your life, or a more platonic one for a friend or family member. We have plenty of options for everyone to enjoy a beautiful piece of jewelry from someone they love this Valentine’s Day. 

Gifts for Him

Are you looking for something he’ll love and cherish, just like he does with you? Look no more, we have our favorite recommendations listed below!

signet ring

Sutton Engravable Signet Ring

Say something special with this Sutton Engravable Signet Ring. You can engrave anything on it, from your initials to your first date. It’s crafted with quality 14k gold and made to last a lifetime. 

Men’s Curb Chain

This Men’s Curb Chain offers a bold, fresh look he is sure to love. It’s crafted with vermeil 14k yellow gold and looks great with anything.

men's curb chain

Gifts for Your Galentine, Friend, or Family Member

If you’re purchasing a gift for a galentine (AKA a best friend) or someone else this Valentine’s Day, we have a couple of options that are made for that person in your life. 

Aspen Bar Necklace 

This Aspen Bar Necklace is the perfect way to share your love. Engrave it with a custom message that means something to the two of you!

engravable bar necklace

Birthstone Earrings

Birthstone earrings are another way to share a bit of sentimentality. Shop our colorful gemstones to pick out a purposeful gift. 

No matter which style you choose this Valentine’s Day, they’re sure to love the sweet, sentimental gift you pick out just for them! Browse our Valentine’s Day Gift Guide for even more suggestions on how to spread the love this holiday.

Notify of
Stay in the Loupe! Sign up for Shane Co. emails

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like