Shopping

How to Find the Perfect Valentine’s Day Gift

Left to Right: 6mm Akoya Cultured Pearl Strand (16 in), Love Letter 14K Yellow Gold Necklace, Terra 0.25 tcw Diamond Oval Huggie Hoops

There’s no better time to celebrate your love than Valentine’s Day, the most romantic day of the year. At Shane Co., we offer the widest selection of unique fine jewelry crafted with care so your love can shine bright.

Jewelry makes the perfect gift. It’ll be a reminder of how much you care, a symbol of your strong connection, and something special to wear every day. Since our jewelry is made so well, it’ll be cherished for years to come.

Here’s the best part: as your friend in the jewelry business, we make it easy for you. So whether you shop at ShaneCo.com or in-store, you’ll have a great experience.

Our Top Gifts for Valentine’s Day

At Shane Co., we’re always bringing in new styles. Our in-house design team travels the world for inspiration. Browse our Valentine’s Day Gift Guide for a curated selection of gift ideas. To help you get started, here are some of our top gift recommendations for your valentine.

Left to Right: 14K Yellow Gold Heart Station Necklace, Cali Paperclip Chain in 14K Yellow Gold (20 in), Love Letter 14K Yellow Gold Necklace

Trending Gifts

Is your valentine someone who loves all the latest styles? If you know they’re a fashionista, they’re going to appreciate anything that’s trending. This Yellow Gold Vermeil T-Bar Paperclip Bracelet is sure to catch the eye of anyone who keeps up with the year’s hottest jewelry styles.

Half-Moon & Oval 2 1/4ct Lab-Grown Diamond Ring, Moondance Multi-Halo Diamond Band, 5 tcw Lab-Grown Diamond Tennis Bracelet

Classic Gifts

Maybe you’re looking for something a little more traditional that you know will stand the test of time. Does your loved one appreciate all the finer things in life and enjoy wearing styles that are always in fashion? You can’t go wrong with something like these gorgeous Monsoon Tanzanite & Diamond Earrings, featuring stunning stones they’re sure to love.

Left to Right: Melina Garnet Pendant – Vermeil 14K Gold, Marzipan 14K White Gold Textured Heart Necklace, Calliope 0.15 tcw Diamond Trio Studs, Epoch Engagement Ring (1 tcw Diamond Accents), Amora Diamond Heart Pendant

Earrings

Earrings are an excellent choice for anyone with a subtle style. Looking for more earring recommendations? We love these Tallulah Freshwater Pearl and Diamond Earrings. They feature both pearls and diamonds, two classics, and are available in 14k white gold, 14k yellow gold, and 14k rose gold. They’re simple, sophisticated, and go with every style.

Bracelets

Show that you’ll love them forever with this Sterling Silver Infinity Paperclip Bracelet. The infinity symbol serves as a focal point of the bracelet, plus it reminds them that your love is everlasting. This sweet statement is sure to go a long way with your valentine. It’s perfect for everyday wear.

Necklaces

Necklaces make for great gifts. Someone may work with their hands, and therefore not like to wear bracelets or rings often. Or, they may not have their ears pierced. Necklaces, though, are a pretty safe bet everyone can enjoy. We recommend this Key to Your Heart Diamond Pendant. The diamonds sparkle and shine against 14k white gold or 14k yellow gold, and the key symbolizes that your love is unlocked.

Rings

A ring, whether given as an engagement ring or a gift, symbolizes eternal love. This Diamond Wrap Ring makes for the perfect gift! Available in 14k white gold, 14k yellow gold, and 14k rose gold, it features seven round natural diamonds. You can even get it engraved with a custom message that’s special between the two of you.

Left to Right: Love Story Amethyst & White Sapphire Pendant, Love Story Garnet & White Sapphire Pendant, Love Story Blue Topaz & White Sapphire Pendant

Gemstone Gifts

If you’re looking for a “wow” factor, a colorful gemstone is sure to impress. We recommend the Desert Rose Morganite & Diamond Halo Ring. Set in rose gold, a peach morganite stone is surrounded by an array of dazzling diamonds. This ring is romantic and will make their Valentine’s Day one to remember forever.

Top to Bottom: Fire Elements Leather Bracelet with Silk & Silver, Adam Leather Bracelet with Silver Accents, Adam Leather Bracelet with Silver & Gold Accents, Earth Elements Leather Bracelet with Silk & Silver

Men’s Jewelry

If you’re searching for the perfect gift for the man in your life, there are plenty of options to choose from this Valentine’s Day. This Gold Miami Cuban Bracelet is one popular choice that fits a lot of personal styles. Expertly crafted with 14k yellow gold, it is made for daily wear and will look great on your man.

Left to Right: 14K Yellow Gold Dog Tag Charm, Odelia Engravable Sterling Silver Pendant, 14K Yellow Gold Engravable Disk Ring

Personalize Your Jewelry

Personalizing a piece of jewelry is a way to make your Valentine’s Day gift extra special. Add a meaningful message, whether it’s a quote, the date you met, or something else that represents your love. This Diamond Accent Engravable Bar Necklace is the perfect template for an engraving that includes up to 10 characters. It’s available in 14k yellow gold, 14k white gold, and 14k rose gold. 

Diamond Link Engagement Ring

Engagement Rings

If you’re looking to make this Valentine’s Day the best one yet, it may be time to propose! Shop our wide selection of engagement rings. You can start with a setting or stone, or you can choose from one of our preset styles. Find the ring that speaks to your love story this Valentine’s Day.

How to Share a Favorites List

If you want to get them something you know they want, or if you want to make a special request for yourself, you can share your favorite items at Shane Co. All you have to do is go to the product you like and click on “Drop a Hint,” located to the right of the product name. From there, enter the email address you want to send your hints to. If you’re not sure what to get your special someone, you can ask that they try this feature out. Get a list of their most desired items straight to your inbox, and they won’t know whether you have purchased them or not.

When to Buy Gifts

Even if you’re shopping up until the eleventh hour this Valentine’s Day, there may still be plenty of time to get your gift from Shane Co.! Here’s everything you need to know about getting gifts close to the holiday:

  • For regular, free 2-day shipping, order your gift by Friday 2/9/24 to get it on time.
  • If you want to personalize a gift, the last day to order and guarantee that it will arrive on time is 2/10/24 with overnight shipping.
  • Select gifts will be available to arrive on time with overnight shipping up until 2/13/24 at noon MST.

How to Make It a Surprise

If you want to make your Valentine’s Day gift really special, we have a few tips for keeping it a surprise. One great way to keep the jewelry a secret until the big day is by letting your valentine know about other plans. For example, if you tell them you made a dinner reservation, they might assume that’s the entirety of your gift and won’t suspect you are also giving them jewelry.

Another way to keep your gift a surprise is by ordering it somewhere away from home, like your office or a friend’s address. This way, if they beat you to getting the mail, they still won’t know about your present.

If you want to let them know there’s a gift but not reveal it until the day of, you can lead up to the big event with smaller gifts. Start with chocolates, roses, or other romantic sentiments. This is a cute way to build anticipation for the final gift.

We Make Finding a Gift Easy

The jewelry consultants at Shane Co. are the best. They’re friendly, knowledgeable, and love to help. They don’t work on commission, so you’ll never feel rushed or pressured. They’ll help you find the perfect gift for your valentine. You can schedule an appointment to meet virtually or at a store near you. Or, chat online with an expert now to get faster help with your order.

Editor’s Note: This post was originally published February 2020 and has been updated for accuracy and comprehensiveness.

This post was last modified on January 17, 2024 1:24 pm

Rachel McCreight

Rachel studied Advertising and English at the University of Georgia. After working in various marketing roles, she decided to focus on two of her passions — writing and style. At Shane Co., she loves writing about all things jewelry! In her free time, she enjoys reading and writing creative fiction.

  • Recent Posts

    Beyond the Derby and Bourbon Trail: Where to Propose in Louisville

    Flowers are blooming, temperatures are rising, and love is in the air this spring, making…

    April 22, 2024

    Spring Proposal Spots in Atlanta

    Spring is in the air, and so is love! If you’re looking for the perfect…

    April 20, 2024

    Spring Proposal Spots in Minneapolis

    Are you proposing this spring? It’s the perfect season to get engaged, with flowers blooming…

    April 19, 2024

    Spring into Style with These Must-Have Jewelry Trends

    Left to Right: Kite-Shaped Green Quartz & Diamond Ring, Dara Cultured Freshwater Pearl Ring, Portia…

    April 16, 2024

    Virtual Try-On: See How You’ll Look with Your Favorite Jewelry

    Left to Right: Voyage Pave Crossover Engagement Ring, Remi Diamond Engagement Ring, Andromeda Chevron Engagement…

    April 11, 2024

    Why Shane Co. Doesn’t Offer Discounts — We Price Fairly and Offer Added Value

    At Shane Co., we’re committed to offering the highest-quality jewelry for our customers. This means…

    March 7, 2024